Haunted Aquia Church, Stafford VA

Posted on June 23, 2024

Aquia Church in Stafford, Virginia, is located off Jefferson Davis Highway and Highway I-95. This unusual church is unique in both design and history and has survived a fire, wars, and a murder most foul.

Before Aquia Church stood the Overwharton Parish from the 1680s, known as the Potomac Church. The newer Aquia Church was built in 1751, housing the new Episocial congregation that had been meeting since 1711. It’s of the Georgian architectural tradition, but it also has some unique features.

First, it’s an example of a Greek cross structure. This type of church is built as a cross when viewed from above. The church also has a full second story. These things make the church a precious historical landmark and are unusual in colonial architecture. It was placed on the National Historic Landmark Registry in 1991.

Thomas Jefferson and George Mason were church members, while George Washington had ties to people who attended.

The current brick church was built in 1751 because the Potomac Church was too far off the rural roads for people to access quickly. During this time, going to church was mandatory, and those who did not go were subjected to fines. Since the Potomac Church was in a bad place and desperately needed repairs, the church decided to build a new one closer to the main road.

In 1745, George Washington’s half-brother Lawrence led the Stafford residents in a campaign to help fund the rebuilding of the Aquia Church. He was the owner of the local ironworks known as Accokeek Furnace. He got the citizens to band together and petitioned the House of Burgess to tax them for rebuilding their church.

Aquia Church had a silver communion set dedicated in 1738. Like the church, the collection has become a symbol of the Church’s resilience against the odds. It was buried before the American Revolution and survived the War of 1812 and the Civil War before being found. The set only comes out for service on Heritage Day and Homecoming services (May and September). It’s still an active church to this day.


The Murder in Aquia Church 


In the mid-1700s, a young blonde woman was traveling the dark country roads of rural Stafford County when a highwaymen group accosted her. This period was rife with uncertainty, exasperated by the war and a lack of resources, food, and money. Men would wait alongside roads to steal valuables from people walking or riding by their hiding spots.

She ran from the men to the sanctuary of a local church. She only managed to hide for a little while before they broke inside and murdered her in cold blood. Her body was hidden in the vestry, a bell-less church tower. Her murderers were never caught.

After the Revolutionary War ended in 1775, Aquia Church was ready to start services again. It was a total shock when the church members discovered a corpse hidden in the vestry. It was obvious the woman had been there for years, decades, even at that point. She was reduced to a skeleton full of beautiful blond hair.

Blood spilled on the vestry floor from her murder could never be removed. Despite using every trick in the book, the bloodstains remained in the tower for over a hundred years. Only then, during a restoration period, the blood was covered up by concrete.

The details of her life, death, and murder are unknown. It’s strange how long she was left in the vestry. It had certainly taken many years for the church to find her, so it would make sense that the woman might find herself attached to the Church since her death.


The Hauntings of Aquia Church 


Such a tragic story seems the perfect fodder for a spooky ghost story. After all, it’s commonly thought that tragic, sudden deaths can cause a person’s spirit to stay behind. They either don’t realize they are dead or are angry and have unfinished business, sometimes revenge, that needs to be met to move on.

Strange things have happened in the church since the woman’s skeleton was discovered. Members of the church have mentioned hearing footsteps walking around at all hours of the day and night. The footsteps will break into a frantic run around the church at night, but no one is there. Noises can be heard in the vestry; some say it sounds like a struggle. There’s sometimes a groan, a whistle, or even a call for help.

Several people have also mentioned seeing a transparent woman in the church’s windows, balcony, or graveyard. The church members have dubbed her Blond Beth due to the hair of the skeleton found upstairs. The haunting is frightening enough that many people avoid it at night when the activity strengthens.

In the 1900s, brave people would try to stay overnight at the church but were chased away by an “unfriendly presence.” A custodian working in the graveyard saw a ghostly woman’s face floating above the graves. Another man saw a woman smiling at him through the balcony windows before she vanished.


The Curious Ghost and Second Civil War


In the 1990s, Aquia Church celebrated its bicentennial anniversary. The church invited a group of Civil War reenactors to pitch their tents on the lawn between the graveyard and the church building. They planned to stay from Saturday night until Sunday. The next morning, Father Kerr of the church spoke with the group before church services began.

While discussing their plans for the day and asking how their night had gone, a few group members admitted they had a strange incident the night before. A man explained to Father Kerr that he had witnessed a red-and-orange flickering light in the vestry. It swayed back and forth and had flickered on and off the entire night. Other people confirmed they had seen the light, too.

One person jokingly suggested it “was the ghost.” Then he told the Father to check out the lightbulb in the vestry–it was probably loose in the socket, and that’s why the light had been flickering all night.

Father Kerr just smiled at the group. Without missing a beat, he explained that the light was probably from Blond Beth, the church’s ghost. He thought she might have been curious about the Civil War soldiers camped on the church’s lawn and why they had returned after a full 200 years since the war had ended.

He also explained to the shocked group that it wasn’t a lightbulb they’d witnessed all night because the vestry had no electrical wiring or lights!


The Church Today


Aquia Church is still in use today. It gives tours to those who make appointments and still holds services. It is the oldest functioning church in the county and plans on staying that way.

They advise that if you want to check out this beautiful and unique building, book your appointment during daylight hours. This way, you won’t be frightened by Blond Beth running past you in the church as she has been doing for centuries. Maybe you’ll get lucky and see her smile at you from the windows.

Keep reading our blog for more macabre tales, and book a Williamsburg ghost tour with Colonial Ghosts to see some of these haunted locations in person.